Skip to main content

Interview with "Abacus: Small Enough to Jail" Director Steve James

When documentary filmmaker Steve James hits the red carpet at tomorrow night's 90th Academy Awards, it will, in my eyes at least, have been a long overdue moment. James was previously nominated for Best Editing for his 1994 masterpiece Hoop Dreams but that great documentary was inexplicably not nominated for Best Documentary Feature. Now James returns to the Oscar race with the Kartemquin Films production Abacus: Small Enough To Jail, a dark horse contender in the doc feature category. Abacus tells the story of the Sung family, owners of the Abacus Federal Savings of Chinatown, New York, who were wrongfully accused of mortgage fraud by the Manhattan District Attorney, as part of the fallout from the 2008 financial crisis.

James sat down with Free Cinema Now to talk about his new film and being recognized by the Academy.

Free Cinema Now: How did this project come to you?

Steve James: It came to my attention through Mark Mitten, one of the producers, who has known the family for over a decade. He learned about what they were going through and that a trail was imminent. [Mitten] decided that this seemed like such a crazy case and it didn't appear that anyone was really following it in the mainstream media at all, so he contacted me and gave me the broad strokes of it. It sounded crazy [to me too]. So we went to New York to shoot, and I was going to decide based on that [footage] whether to continue or not. By day two, I was like, "Okay. We're doing this."

FCN: Early in the film you reference the visual of the Abacus employees, chained together by handcuffs, being led down a hallway after arrest. A talking ahead later makes the comment that never would've happened with a "black group of employees." It's even more shocking to learn that three of those Abacus employees were already indicted and they were still posed to be shackled for the press photo op. Steve, your profession is in convincing the public with the images you present; your film tells a story very much in the same vein: Using images to sway public opinion. Can you share your thoughts on this?

SJ: Yeah, that was archival footage that we got. We managed to use both stuff from news stories and raw footage of the walk down the hallway -- which was really good to get -- so that we could mix the two together. And then [we] combined that with interviews to provide this other perspective on what you're actually watching, because if you just looked at the people being led down the hallway in chains, you don't have a whole lot of context for that; you could think these are some really bad people.

It's interesting that in The New York Times -- which did exactly two articles on this case, that indictment and then the jury's decision three years later -- there's nothing [in their] article about the indictment that says anything, [or is] editorializing, [on] the spectacle of these people being chained together or that they're low level bank employees. It obviously worked for [District Attorney Cyrus] Vance; his intentions were to paint these people as "bad people" and somehow worthy of being shackled together and led down the hallway. It got the attention he wanted to. By giving you the raw footage, without reporters prattling over it, is towards building a different kind of look than what was intended by the people who orchestrated [that spectacle].

FCN: (Nodding) So you broke down [the initial imagery] and then put it back together again. When I was first watching it, I was like, "Whoa"; that footage of them in shackles didn't sit well with me. Then we see the clip again later, but with commentary, and then we see it again, but with different context. 

SJ: And then there's another part -- after Polly Greenberg lies, literally, and says that it wasn't their decision to shackle them together, that it was the court officer's decision -- where we show you a piece [of the footage] again and have Chanterelle [Sung] tell you that that's not true, that they were being led down the hallway by D.A. detectives and we freeze [the frame] on them so you can see it.

All of that is just to show what Vance was trying to run away from it in his interview, [when he was] saying it was "unfortunate," you know, "feelings were hurt" or whatever; we decided to make a pretty big meal of that section because we felt there was a lot of complexity to what was going on there that you would miss otherwise.

FCN: I was thinking about Blowup. I was reminded of him coming back to the image...I look at that whole section [in Abacus] like its own little mini-movie! You think it's "this" but then...shit, it's "that." 

SJ: (Laughs) I'll take the Blowup reference. That's pretty great.

FCN: It's hard to make courtroom drama memorable today in movies. We've almost seen it all, let alone in documentaries. Your film has a striking approach to the images in court -- like the volume levels used for captioning Ken Yu's phone conversations. There were also several shots of empty seats in the court while the soundtrack played the audio of the defendants, plaintiffs and witnesses. How did you and your cinematographer arrive at this visual strategy?

SJ: We knew early on that the court case was going to be an engine for the film [in addition to] how the Sungs were dealing with it. But we didn't know what scenes, out of this 7,000-page transcript from the five-month trial, that we were going to isolate and feature until we got into editing. So, during the trial we hired Christine Cornell, this incredible New York City courtroom artist, to go in and spend a few days and make these drawings. They became a foundation for what we showed in the film, once we started editing those sequences together.

The courtroom sequences are made up of various elements. With the graphics team we came up with this visual representation to show those kinds of [audio] recordings. Then we also used the "empty courtroom [look]." When we went that day to shoot [in the empty courtroom] I had generated a whole list of the kinds of shots that I was looking for, plus [cinematographer] Tom Bergmann is a really great shooter, so it was a very collaborative day in terms of ideas I walked in with and then ideas you think of in the moment. I just didn't want the courtroom parts of the film to feel like "Oh, we're back in the courtroom..." (I knew the family was going to be really engaging outside the courtroom in what they were going through.) But all that courtroom stuff was a challenge in every regard.

FCN: I know you were recognized by The Academy for your editing but you should've been nominated for Best Documentary for Hoop Dreams over twenty years ago. How does this nomination in the Best Documentary category resonate with you?

SJ: When we got the nomination, it was great! It was great for a lot of reasons. One of them is -- this is a small film. It's not as ambitious an undertaking as some of the other films that I've done, including Hoop Dreams. [Plus] the fact that members of the branch took a film like this, and really saw what I think we managed to accomplish as filmmakers, was meaningful. But of course, even more meaningful, was that people really fell in love with this family [the Sungs] and were both moved and humored and then infuriated at the D.A.'s office on their behalf. All those things made it satisfying but I also that back on the other works [that I've done]; I thought back on Hoop Dreams, The Interrupters -- and not like "Oh they should've been nominated!" but [in the sense that] I've been really fortunate to follow the lives of some pretty extraordinary people in my view. To be let into their lives. And to be let into their lives at critical junctures.

So I thought about all those folks when I managed to sit back and reflect on [this Oscar nomination].


Watch the trailer for Abacus: Small Enough To Jail below.


Popular posts from this blog

Winnie the Pooh Mashup Trailer: "Christopher Robin & Ted"

"Sooner or later, your past catches up to you." That's the tagline  Disney is going with for their live-action Winnie the Pooh movie Christopher Robin , starring Ewan McGregor . While watching the teaser trailer (which debuted today) and getting my first look at a real life Winnie the Pooh talking bear, I couldn't help but be reminded of  Seth MacFarlane 's Ted , the R-rated comedy which featured a protagonist who's a foul-mouthed talking teddy bear. Ironically enough, MacFarlane's talking bear Ted has a much more cuddly and lovable look to him. Disney decided to give Winnie the Pooh a crude and homely-looking appearance -- not exactly what you'd expect for their intended child audience. So I decided to create this mashup trailer, which rewrites Christopher Robin's (McGregor) backstory to suggest that Ted was his original bear and he just sewed up the teddy bear's parts to look like Winnie the Pooh. Talk about your past catching up to y

Watch: Errol Morris' 1991 Documentary on Stephen Hawking, "A Brief History of Time"

Yesterday we learned that the brilliant and world-renowned theoretical physicist  Stephen Hawking  passed away at the age of 76. In the early 1960s,  Hawking developed an early form of motor neurone disease, debilitating and paralyzing him throughout the decades. However, he did not let such a devastating physical disability stop him from becoming a truly iconic figure, thinker and leader in the sciences, and in specific, cosmology. Hawking's built a legacy of scientific works, breakthroughs and publications throughout his academic career but it was his best selling book "A Brief History of Time" that caught the eye of acclaimed documentary filmmaker Errol Morris (Oscar winner for  The Fog of War: Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNamara ). Morris' doc A Brief History of Time  looks at the impressive life and work of Hawking, told in the signature way that only Morris can, all scored to a soundtrack composed by  Philip Glass . While the film is ava

Watch: ALL OF VENOM: Mashup of “All of Me” and “Venom”

Venom , the latest Marvel (anti) superhero film, limps into theatres this weekend with an unimpressive 30% on Rotten Tomatoes . However, I'm sure that won't prevent it from making boo koo bucks at the box office. What I'm more interested in is how Venom will fit into the annals of film history -- because it does! While this isn't my first Venom mashup video (see my The Venom Drop teaser trailer), I do think that my new mashup, All Of Venom , really speaks to what Venom  ultimately will be remembered for:  Tom Hardy 's committed physical performance and how it plays as a companion piece to the 1984 romantic fantasy comedy All of Me starring ( Steve Martin and Lily Tomlin ). In Venom , Hardy's character Eddie Brock gets possessed by an alien symbiote and must learn to share his host body with said being. In All of Me , Martin's character gets possessed by the soul of the recently deceased Edwina Cutwater (Tomlin) and -- yup, you guessed it -- must lea

#InformedImages: “There Will Be Blood” and “Narcos: Mexico”

#InformedImages is a Free Cinema Now series that studies and brings to light influential films and other examples of moving images that informed and inspired specific visuals in later works. I remember the exact the moment it clicked together for me. It was about half an hour into episode 2 (directed by  Josef Kubota Wladyka ) of Narcos: Mexico on Netflix . The camera crept across the dry, desert landscape toward a hole in the ground, where Rafael Caro Quintero (a.k.a. Rafa, played by Tenoch Huerta Mejía ) was digging furiously, in an attempt create a makeshift aqueduct to help grow his field of marijuana. It recalled images from the earlier sections of Paul Thomas Anderson 's masterpiece T here Will Be Blood, when Daniel Plainview (played by Daniel Day-Lewis ) was digging for oil underneath the rocky ground. Then, as I continued to watch Narcos: Mexico , a more striking visual parallel to There Will Be Blood began to emerge. For example, as Rafa and his boss Miguel Ángel F

VIDEO ESSAY: Paul Thomas Anderson's "The Master"

"He's making all this up as he goes along." NOTE:  I was fortunate enough to attend a rare 70mm screening of Paul Thomas Anderson's The Master on Thursday August 16, 2012 at the Music Box Theatre in Chicago, Illinois. In attendance were writer/director Paul Thomas Anderson and one of the film's actors, Kevin J. O'Connor (both of whom are pictured with me here ). --   The key to the success of Paul Thomas Anderson 's The Master doesn't come in its mammoth achievement of being shot on 70mm film or its carefully constructed parallel origin story of L. Ron Hubbard's Scientology practices. Rather, that success is embedded in an intimate scene: a single shot close-up on alcoholic war veteran Freddie Sutton (an unforgettable Joaquin Phoenix ) during a "process of time" session with Lancaster Dodd ( Philip Seymour Hoffman in prime Hubbard form). Up until this scene, the character of Freddie dutifully performed the task of delive

Review: "Loveless"

Some people should never get married. Likewise, some people should never become parents. Crudely enough, the protagonists of  Andrey Zvyagintsev 's new film Loveless fit both of those descriptions. The Leviathan helmer returns with another bleak and unflinchingly honest portrayal of family dysfunction and social politics. Loveless is also a commentary on modern Moscow. Zvyagintsev uses the car radio as the film's cultural master of ceremonies, informing the audience of the state of Russia, the political climate and expected societal norms. In fact, the only other time the car radio isn't used for exposition, is when a character turns it into an aural weapon to antagonize another character, by blaring loud metal rock during an inappropriate time. The coal-hearted characters in Loveless listen to the radio, but hardly to each other. Early in the film we learn that Zhenya ( Maryana Spivak ) and Boris ( Aleksey Rozin ) are in the final steps of finalizing their divorce.

Review: "November"

The protagonist of Estonian filmmaker Rainer Sarnet 's  Where Souls Go (from 2007), a fifteen-year-old girl named Ann, sets the plot in motion when she visits a satanist's website and says a prayer (in an effort to seek solutions) that inadvertently gives her newborn stepbrother a heart disease. Ann also has a poster for The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King on her bedroom wall, prominent in many shots of the film. This image is a strong representation of Sarnet's interests: to acknowledge how fantasy (with its mythical creatures and wish-granting powers) shares an overlap with hell (and its evil incarnates). Considering this, it's no wonder that Sarnet chose to adapt Andrus Kivirähk 's novel " Rehepapp ," which focuses on 19th-century Estonian village peasants and the dead souls that lurk in the forest, for his latest film November . How can I best describe November ? Well, it's as if Michael Haneke 's The White Ribbon was re-constr

Watch: Gaspar Noe's ENTER THE CATS

It's been quite the day for trailers. Ad Astra . It Chapter Two . Top Gun: Maverick . But I don't think anyone was REALLY ready for the promised "digital fur technology" of Tom Hooper 's Cats . The trailer is pure nightmare fuel. While watching it, the first thing that struck me was how dark and dreadful the film looked. Like physically and literally. I started thinking about how the film would probably be enjoyable while on some drugs. Then I started fixating on a shot of Idris Elba on top of a multi-colored lit building and the poster for Gaspar Noe 's Enter The Void  suddenly popped in my head. And after that, there was no turning back...

Watch: PERFECT PIKACHU (Mashup of "Pokémon Detective Pikachu" and "Perfect")

On Tuesday May 7th,  Warner Bros. and Ryan Reynolds trolled the Internet by pretending to upload the entire  Pokémon Detective Pikachu  movie to YouTube, a couple of days before its theatrical release. As I type this, the  YouTube video  -- which actually shows Pikachu working out to some 80s jazzercise music -- has 1,441,931 views and counting. It's a clever marketing ploy, feeding right into the piracy culture of the interwebs and poking fun at the rick-rolling clickbait urgency.  Within moments of watching this rick-roll video, I recalled the 1985 romance-fitness club-meet cute that is Perfect , starring John Travolta and Jamie Lee Curtis . Then the idea clicked to replace Curtis with Pikachu can just watch for yourself...

VIDEO ESSAY: Film Fidelity: Beyoncé's "Lemonade"

Beyoncé knocked the wind out of the Internet when she dropped her nearly hour-long visual album Lemonade on HBO this past Saturday night, April 23rd. The inspired film is a remarkable piece to be sure--even for the Queen Bee herself. And while everything from the sound design to the collective creative direction from the team of filmmakers, editors and art department is exceptional, much of the receptive chatter online has instead circled around the implied infidelity that spurs the narrative of Lemonade ; the idea that hubby Jay Z did Beyoncé wrong with a certain "Becky with the good hair." Which is too bad; that's the kind of fodder for tabloids and it marginalizes how much great film art is packed into this thing. So, as a reactionary cinephile, I thought I'd redirect the public's attention to the striking images that Lemonade presents, the ideas behind them and, more pointedly, where these vignettes drew inspiration from. In contrast to the possi